Skip to main content

The Negative Vote


Decentralisation of power is a powerful concept and democracy does it take it to its ultimate logical end. By allowing the people to be governed to decide who will govern the community. Asking a person, what he wants and by whom we wants to be governed, is respecting the basic dignity of human being and respecting her/his innate intelligence. But, quite clearly even if we are voting intelligently individually, we are not voting intelligently collectively. The power that the voters were supposed to have wielded is practically non-existent. The political parties have been able to use a combination of charisma, lineage, fear, ‘inducement’, caste, alliance arithmetic, poll management, information inefficiency, to get candidates with dubious credentials get elected. As a result sometimes ineffective governments have returned to power [Left Bloc in West Bengal for 20 years] or the relatively effective governments given way to a less effective dispensations [there are many examples in the past 30 years, Kalyan Singh – UP, PV Narasimha Rao – Centre, Atal Behari Vajpayee – Centre, etc].    

Quite inevitably, there are strident demands to change our election system. The Right to Reject, The Right to Recall – being two such changes mooted; wherein re-elections would need to be held if unacceptable candidates are fielded or if the elected candidates do not deliver. The Right to Reject and Right to Re-call, are essentially the call to give power to voice of dis-satisfaction. Considering that in the last 40 years of Indian general elections, only once has a party been voted to power based on a promise [BJP under Atal Behari Vajpayee] and not on an anti-incumbency wave, it is absolutely critical to respect the voice of dissent.

Most elections are fought on attacking the poor governance of an incumbent and the incumbent trying hard to protect its turf. In such a scenario, to appropriately reflect the popularity of a candidate all negative votes need to be consolidated. Interestingly, the election arithmetic dissipates the election impact of any other negative sentiment by distributing the anti-incumbency [or other negative wave] votes among multiple parties. Thus making it less difficult for parties/candidates carrying a negative sentiment to get their desired electoral outcomes.

That takes us to the negative vote. Wherein, the voter has to option to either cast a positive vote for or a negative vote against any candidate. The total positive votes less the total negative votes will be the net vote of a candidate and the candidate with maximum net vote wins. This would better consolidate the voice of negative sentiment and will give the requisite power to shape election results – and governments such as the one currently at the centre will not have any chance to come back to power. Even a opportunistically aggregated conglomerate of regional parties will provide better governance than the current dispensation – at least it will give the nation as choice and will keen under check the tendency amongst incumbents to get arbitrary and arrogant.

The negative vote, will have another power. As the real popularity is reflected in net votes – which are expected to be abysmal – entry barriers for educated, committed and capable candidates will dramatically fall. This challenge the status-quo of the current oligarchy [read oligopoly], where one candidate with vested interests replaces a look alike. Fresh faces, with a positive agenda can use targeted guerilla tactics to fell the Goliaths with one-tenth the resources [men, money, material and votes!!]. Thus, the negative vote – has the power to transform the quality of the representatives that are sent to the parliament / assemblies / local bodies / gram panchayats. It will either bust bad candidates or it will force established parties to field better candidates. Either way, the quality of elected representatives will substantially improve.


Bhubaneswar
May 18, 2013

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dura Pahada Sundara [Far-away Mountains are Beautiful]

I realize how seriously we take a place we visit specifically to see it – an event in itself, and how much taken for granted are those places that we can hop in an out with regularity and ease. Interestingly I had never wrote or thought of writing about Puri or Konark or Cuttack. Places for which reams have been and can be written. The history, the culture, the cuisine and the local chutzpah [espl. Puri / Cuttack]. Even more interestingly, I have never pondered enough on these places and their unique niceties to have them simmering in my cerebral consciousness. They are somewhere deep there sedimented at best; and at [likely] worst, I do not have the desired ammunition to do justice to write anything substantial. Probably, I will have to resort to the frivolous flourish of the might of the language as a cover. A point to note - I have never seen the Bali Yatra [Cuttackis don’t faint please]. The Puri beach and temple I have always felt is my backyard [so had the taken for granted attit
4 comments
Read more

Foreign Universities in India: Boon or Bane?

    Dr. Partha S Mohapatra (Originally written in March, 2010)   The cabinet yesterday gave its nod to the “Foreign Universities Bill”. I first read the report on Wall Street Journal about the Indian Governments’ intention to open up the higher education sector to foreign universities [Delhi Seeks to Admit Foreign Universities,  Wall Street Journal June 11, 2009 ].  Subsequently, I read similar reports in other newspapers.  Most of the se reports make a compelling story to allow foreign universities to operate in India. The main argument that is made is on following premises: i)      It will save India about $4 billion in foreign exchange [“Leading foreign institutes may soon be here” Economic Times , 11 Sep 2006”]. ii)    India loses because of brain drain when brilliant people go abroad and study and stay there. iii)   We need foreign investments because the government does not have money needed to invest in higher education and private sector is unwilling
41 comments
Read more

Energising The Employability Magic Of Professional Education

The private engineering colleges and b-schools are going through another bad phase. The overcapacity, because of which many colleges are reeling under significant financial stress, is intriguing when seen against the backdrop of a modest Gross Enrollment Ratio. The reasons are quite straight forward, students enroll into professional education for jobs.  Starting from the mid-1990s, riding on an economy growing at a fast clip with the promise of dollar jobs students thronged the higher education professional courses. When the global economies plateaued and the Indian growth rate isn’t much better, job creation is poor and so also is the demand to join professional courses. The professional education institutes, must know that the role they need to play is to create industry worthy professionals. That needs to be the focus.  For the past 20 years, institutes have focussed on two areas – infrastructure and admission network. This strategy worked, when large organized businesses h
8 comments
Read more